Why a strong start to the earnings season won’t stop the decline in global stocks
The Wall Street sign can be seen in front of the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) in New York on February 16, 2021.
Brendan McDermid | Reuters
LONDON – The corporate earnings season has got off to a rapid start, but the positive surprises have so far not created any upward momentum in global equity markets.
By Friday morning, 13% of companies in Europe and 20% in the US had reported earnings for the first quarter, with the majority beating consensus expectations.
Barclays analysts highlighted on Friday that earnings per share (EPS) growth has been particularly strong at 107% year-over-year in Europe and 63% in the US
Barclays pointed out that EPS beats are above average for a reporting season of 74% in Europe and 83% in the US, while sales growth versus consensus in Europe has surprised positively, with 4% leading the beats in US financials All European financial stocks have delivered positive surprises in terms of earnings per share so far.
Both European and US markets are slightly bearish this week, however, and Barclays head of European equity strategy Emmanuel Cau suggested that high earnings expectations are largely priced into the markets after their impressive run and revaluation over the past year were.
“Our view that reporting season could turn out to be a ‘travel and get-there’ case seems to be emerging so far,” Cau said in the note.
“The average stock price response to the results is indeed negative, despite strong estimates, especially in the US, while it is largely flat in Europe.”
Cau noted that a similar pattern had emerged in the previous two profit seasons, with stock markets rebounding before they stalled and recovering after a period of digestion.
Marcus Morris-Eyton, portfolio manager at Allianz Global Investors, told CNBC on Thursday that earnings season is expected to be strong due to “very healthy macroeconomic tailwinds” and that it is expected to continue into the next few quarters, particularly in Europe.
“The challenge for us as investors, however, is that expectations are very high. Therefore, these companies must either meet or exceed expectations,” Morris-Eyton told CNBC’s “Squawk Box Europe”.
“You’ve seen quite a few examples of companies reporting inline numbers before, but it wasn’t good enough for the market.”
Robust earnings will be important for equity markets to continue their general uptrend, but overbought technicals, largely bullish positioning, and the seasonal “sell in May” mindset could put stocks in the “danger zone” for retreat if a negative catalyst occurs. Suggested Cau.
“Most obvious would be the emergence of a vaccine-resistant (coronavirus) variant, but geopolitical flares or a Hawk political surprise could also hurt sentiment,” he said.
“We also recently warned of regulatory / tax risks that have been largely ignored by the markets.”
The latter came to the fore on Thursday as the markets were startled by reports that the administration of US President Joe Biden is considering increasing capital gains tax as part of its new economic package.
“Many indicators have been stretched for some time and it would have been premature to reduce risk in the face of improving fundamentals, but there now seems to be less room for error should something go wrong,” said Cau.
Subscribe to CNBC PRO for exclusive insights and analysis, as well as live business day programs from around the world.